
It wasn't too long ago that enjoying an independent film required accepting a few cut corners. It certainly wasn't the place to go to see state-of-the-art computer generated visuals, or to even see complicated camera work. ("Clerks" was released sixteen years ago, but putting it up against the "modern independent film" (urgh), it feels more like forty.) To make an independent film was to make something that the major studios wouldn't touch and the minor studios could not afford to bet their existence on. They were strange, in other words, and possibly a little too personal.
In certain aspects, "He Was A Quiet Man" feels like a throwback to the original spirit of independent films: it contains an unsettling story, too dark for most studios wanting to put bank on it, but it is consistently quirky enough to make it through watching at least one time. There are also enough baffling choices by the filmmakers that keep this from being the classic that could have been.
The film revolves around Bob Maconel, played by Christian Slater under a lot of makeup (and yet somehow still looks like the 80's icon). Bob is a headcase, hopeless romantic, and matchstick artist all rolled into one. As part of his workday routine, he loads a revolver at his cubicle, counting off and naming each of his victims, before chickening out and resuming his work. In a series of quick coincidences, though, he ends up looking like a hero when he kills another coworker who goes postal before Bob can. Suddenly, Bob has to cope with being happy with his social standing after years of misery, a task that proves much more difficult than his previous miserable existence. On top of that, a cute coworker shooting victim, Venessa Parks (played by Elisha Cuthbert, of "Old School", "The Girl Next Door", and the television series "24" fame), has an unusual request for Bob.
It's best to start with what this film does well, because the final score is heavily offset by its devastating flaws despite doing a lot of things right. To begin with, "He Was A Quiet Man" does not look like an independent film. The writer/director, Frank Cappello, is an accomplished CGI artist, and was able to offset the budget for the special effects by doing them himself. This allows for shots of airplanes, potty-mouthed goldfish, and an entire alternate ending sequence that required no extra participation from the actors after filming wrapped. With the majority of independent films willing to use any workarounds they can for fantastical images, it is refreshing to see a film not use any and just show off its imagination. The color schemes for each scene are also sharp and distinct. It's not on par with "One Hour Photo", but it's better than most films, indie or not.
The performance that the cast gives exceeds expectations, at the very least. Slater plays Bob perfectly--an unsettling presence when he needs to be, but also likable enough to feel for the character when the story requires as much. The bigger revelation, though, might actually be Cuthbert. Though often cast as a pretty face and/or the object of lust, she is actually a very energetic and interesting person with a lot of untapped potential, judging by sit-down interviews she has done (including keeping up with Conan O'Brien at his manic peak). The role of Venessa requires her to play the role of a optimistic blond as well as a pessimistic quadriplegic, and she rises to both occasions. This isn't the kind of movie to look for future Oscar winners, but Cuthbert shows that she deserves meatier roles than she usually gets, if nothing else. The rest of the cast is made up of office stereotypes and suburban WASP-types, with the exception of William H. Macy as the company boss, who manages to simultaneously inspire hatred and laughter from the audience (intentionally) with every line despite never raising his voice and never telling a joke. He's a snake-oil salesman, and nobody is fooled by his act, which is why the character works.
With all this going for it, "He Was A Quiet Man" might sound like an underappreciated classic. The few flaws that the film has, though, are almost fatal. The biggest issue is that it can't decide what it wants to be. It begins as "Taxi Driver", changes to "Queen For A Day" in the middle, and the last third resembles "Donnie Darko". Granted, each section of the movie works well enough in their own vacuums, but the final third rings false after a great second act. Cuthbert and Slater have a warped chemistry that works very well--too well, in fact, as the romance between their characters ends up being more interesting than Bob's psychology. The turn that the film makes in its last twenty minutes feels tacked on and predictable--incalculably harmful for a film that had been unpredictable up until this point.
That's not taking into account the ending of the film, which almost destroys the worth of the film. I'll avoid spoilers, but suffice it to say that the ending is such a confusing mess that I had to watch the movie again with the director's commentary on to figure out what had happened. It turns out that he was attempting to cram a series finale's worth of tied-up plot points and deus ex machina into about 2 minutes. The ending he eventually decided on is better than either of the 2 alternate endings presented on the DVD, but that is faint praise.
Cappello admits that there was a long period of time between writing the film and the film's production, and that he respected his original script the same way that he would respect a script written by someone else. That is a brave decision, and one that is hard to fault, but much of the film's worst flaws could have been fixed with extensive rewriting. As it is, the film's end feels like it occurs about 65 minutes into it, which is a problem since it is actually 90 minutes long. If I were to rework it, the film's second act would have been extended by 15 minutes, and the film's third act would have either been excised or rewritten to the point of being unrecognizable. In the end, the film does lots of little things right. It is just unfortunate that it does a few big things wrong.
Score (out of 100): 59


